Plantless crops

Alternative indoor methods of crop production aiming to grow fruits without the plant in a laboratory through producing fruits from meristem cells.

lab table with tomatoes

This innovation centres around alternative indoor methods of crop production, aiming to grow fruits without the plant. This is being attempted by collecting immature fruit or flowers from tomato plants to try to grow them into healthy, high-quality tomatoes in the lab. Ultimately, the current goal is to produce fruit from tomato meristem cells, which are undifferentiated cells from which new plant organs can grow, thereby avoiding using a plant entirely. In theory, this could become a sustainable food production method that returns agricultural land to nature.

 

Food System Area

agricultural inputs & primary production practiceswaste

The overarching problem this innovation is addressing is reducing the agricultural footprint. Agriculture now takes up half of Earth’s hospitable land surface and contributes significantly to global greenhouse gas emissions. Lab-grown crops could cut significant inputs, including the agricultural land itself, its maintenance, fertilizers and pesticides, and energy and labor inputs, from the production process. It could additionally remove the risks of worsening environmental conditions, promoting resilient and reliable crop production in the face of climate change.

Problem area

reducing agricultural footprintincreasing climate resilience

What impact could it have?

What factors influence scaling?

No investment trends are currently available for this innovation, due to its extremely early stages. However, generally, investment trends for next-generation crops are characterized by a growing commitment to agricultural innovation and sustainability. Investors are increasingly directing funds toward crop research and development that focuses on traits such as improved resilience to climate change, enhanced nutritional content, and higher yields with reduced resource inputs. With recent developments in genetic editing techniques, with the CRISPR-Cas9 genome editing technology, this field is attracting substantial investments.

This innovation should be bundled with renewable energy integration to power the laboratory operations. It may also be bundled with various genetic modifications to increase nutrient values or add other desirable traits to the crops.

This innovation may technically be applicable on a global scale, though it requires higher-tech laboratory equipment and space.

Large scale food actors are most likely to take up the innovation, due its highly-technological aspect requiring adequate funding and presumably expensive equipment.

This innovation may highly disrupt the entire agricultural inputs and primary production system. However, there may be lower levels of disruption for other parts of the food system such as handlers and distributors. Consumers may also be disrupted, due to the social acceptance barriers of lab-grown food.

Currently, only Wageningen University seems to be working on this technology, with Lucas van der Zee leading the research.

There may be unintended consequences related to the quality and nutritional value of such lab-grown crops, though these will be explored in the research and development phase of the innovation. Re-wilding lands that can be reclaimed from previous agricultural use may also have various unintended consequences to the ecosystem, though not necessarily bad.

Lucas van der Zee, a horticulture and product physiologist at Wageningen University, the Netherlands, is currently researching this innovation for his PhD.
scientist in laboratory wearing blue gloves examining fresh tomato cut in half with petri dish and glassware for food research and biotechnology

Where is acceleration most needed?

Accelerator scores reflect the degree of action needed across eight key accelerators of change that can enable an innovation to scale. A higher score signals that greater effort and support are needed in that area to unlock uptake at scale. Click on each accelerator to see what’s been achieved and what still needs attention.

Building Trust

High level
High

Building Trust

A completely new and disruptive approach to cultivation will require extreme measures for building trust amongst actors in the food system.

Transforming Mindsets

High level
High

Transforming Mindsets

Due to the futuristic and ‘artificial’ manner of production, social acceptance is likely to be a large barrier for this innovation.

Enabling Social License

High level
High

Enabling Social License

Enabling social licence is essential for this innovation to gain funding and progress.

Ensuring Stable Finance

High level
High

Ensuring Stable Finance

This innovation requires stable finance to grow research and development efforts, of which much more is needed before this innovation can reach any form of success.

Designing Market Incentives

High level
High

Designing Market Incentives

Spread costs and risks associated with this innovation, as it is a completely new and disruptive approach to food production, is essential.

Changing Policies and Regulations

High level
High

Changing Policies and Regulations

Integrating such technologies in health and safety standards will take a long time and be essential for this innovation.

Safeguarding Against Undesirable Effects

High level
High

Safeguarding Against Undesirable Effects

Monitoring for unintended consequences, both for the products of this innovation as well as the consequences of repurposing previous agricultural lands is crucial.

Developing Transition Pathways

High level
High

Developing Transition Pathways

Developing transition pathways for possible integration of this alternative cultivation method is essential for its chance in scaling up and contributing to food production.

Reference

Mitchell Crow, J. (2023). My mission to grow fruit without the plant. In Nature (Vol. 618, Issue 7964, pp. 426–426). Springer Science and Business Media LLC. https://doi.org/10.1038/d41586-023-01834-z

Other Innovations