Precision feeding technologies

The application of process engineering techniques to livestock feeding to automatically monitor, model and manage animal feeding at the individual level.

person holding tablet showing smart livestock farming interface in barn with cows illustrating digital agriculture technology

Priorities for scaling

high-risk pilotingcatalysing researchcatalysing development

This is a set of innovations based on the application of process engineering principles and techniques to livestock feeding to automatically monitor, model and manage animal feeding at the individual level. The basic idea is not new and has been used to maximise margins for intensive livestock production for many years. It is developing to encompass a wide range of new monitoring and sensor technologies, and there is literature on its application to the major domesticated livestock species, including cattle, sheep, goats, pigs and poultry. The economic and environmental impacts of these new technologies are highly context dependent.

Food System Area

agricultural inputs & primary production practices

The primary goal is to minimize the environmental impact of animal agriculture, focusing on enhancing efficiency in water, feed, land, and emissions management. This innovation holds the potential to reduce the consumption of water, feed, and land while lowering emission intensities of livestock products (i.e. emissions per unit of meat or milk).

Problem area

reducing agricultural footprintincreasing [system] productivity

What impact could it have?

What factors influence scaling?

To date, technological developments to increase the sustainability of livestock production have depended largely on public investment and philanthropy. This is likely to continue in the short-to-medium term, as animal welfare and environmental issues come increasingly to the fore. Future private investment will be heavily dependent on the economic viability of specific sustainable livestock technologies.

Precision livestock feeding could be bundled with animal health, fertility, and behavior monitoring as part of a broader strategy for "precision livestock farming."

The innovation is currently limited to regions with accessible hardware supply, maintenance, and analytical services.

Initially, this innovation is best suited for medium- to large-scale, highly intensive livestock operations. Barriers to adoption include substantial initial costs, ongoing maintenance, skilled labor requirements, and accessibility. It remains uncertain how this innovation could be made feasible for small-scale, less intensive producers.

Producers may experience medium to high disruption, especially in managing the innovation package, which could be resource-intensive and require specialized knowledge.

Multiple organizations and research entities are actively involved in advancing precision livestock feeding.

Adoption at scale could lead to an overall increase in livestock production, potentially resulting in net increases in greenhouse gas emissions. There could also be concerns regarding technology supply concentration and ownership of monitoring data with implications for privacy policy.

Few life cycle assessments of precision feeding have been done, focusing on the environmental impacts. In general, it is still not clear that information derived from using precision farming technologies results in improved value (Rojo-Gimeno et al., 2019). Few if any investment analyses appear to have been done as yet.
A close up shot of a veterinarian in white gloves giving an injection to a cow using a syringe

Where is acceleration most needed?

Accelerator scores reflect the degree of action needed across eight key accelerators of change that can enable an innovation to scale. A higher score signals that greater effort and support are needed in that area to unlock uptake at scale. Click on each accelerator to see what’s been achieved and what still needs attention.

Building Trust

Medium level
Medium

Building Trust

Achieving trust in this innovation necessitates robust evidence of its economic benefits for producers, along with considerations of animal welfare and environmental implications.

Transforming Mindsets

Low level
Low

Transforming Mindsets

The general social acceptability of the innovation is uncertain but may not pose a significant challenge.

Enabling Social License

Low - Medium level
Low - Medium

Enabling Social License

Stakeholder dialogue, particularly concerning animal welfare and broader environmental aspects, may be required.

Ensuring Stable Finance

Medium level
Medium

Ensuring Stable Finance

The long-term viability of subscription-based financial models for this innovation, even in highly intensive livestock operations, is unclear, and robust evidence is lacking.

Designing Market Incentives

High level
High

Designing Market Incentives

Determining suitable market incentives to reduce risks and costs across different contexts is uncertain without credible financial performance data.

Changing Policies and Regulations

Low - Medium level
Low - Medium

Changing Policies and Regulations

The innovation may necessitate modifications to health, safety and animal welfare regulations.

Safeguarding Against Undesirable Effects

High level
High

Safeguarding Against Undesirable Effects

Ongoing monitoring is essential to assess long-term impacts on production, producer incomes, animal welfare, and overall greenhouse gas emissions and other environmental indicators.

Developing Transition Pathways

High level
High

Developing Transition Pathways

The lack of robust information on impacts and how the innovation fits into a declining emissions trajectory in the livestock sector makes understanding transition pathways challenging.

Reference

Chase LE, Fortina R, 2023. Environmental and Economic Responses to Precision Feed Management in Dairy Cattle Diets. Agriculture 13(5), p.1032.

 

Mackenzie SG, 2023. The Potential Contribution of Smart Animal Nutrition in Reducing the Environmental Impacts of Livestock Systems. In Smart Livestock Nutrition (pp. 311-336). Cham: Springer International Publishing.

 

Rojo-Gimeno C et al., 2019. Assessment of the value of information of precision livestock farming: A conceptual framework. NJAS-Wageningen Journal of Life Sciences, 90, p.100311

 

Tullo E et al., 2019. Environmental impact of livestock farming and Precision Livestock Farming as a mitigation strategy. Science of the total environment 650, 2751-2760.

 

Zuidhof MJ, 2020. Precision livestock feeding: matching nutrient supply with nutrient requirements of individual animals. Journal of Applied Poultry Research 29(1), 11-14.

Other Innovations